Two Panels from Civil Architecture: Treason of Judas and the Miracle of St. Nicolas (?)
, France, School of Provence, Avignon?, first quarter of the 16th century
Two Panels from Civil Architecture: Treason of Judas and the Miracle of St. Nicolas (?)
Description
These two rectangular civil panels constitute elements of larger compositions. One panel illustrates the Treason of Judas; he receives the purse with the thirty pieces of silver in front of a group of nimbed apostles. A similar, now lost, panel would have shown those who gave him the money on the right. The other panel illustrates a horse and charioteer in front of a group of seated spectators; this might be the right side of a scene of the story of the debtor of bad faith, which is one of the miracles from the life of Saint Nicolas. The figures are of remarkably high quality, both in their design and execution. Note especially the heads of the group of innocent apostles, including the apostle whose face is buried in a book, and their contrast with the coarse features of Judas.
The curious style of the panels recalls two paintings related by Dominique Thiébaut to the School of Provence and specifically to the entourage of Josse Lieferinxe (Marseilles and Avignon, active c. 1493-1505-08). Both paintings are in Cambridge in the Fogg Museum of Art (Thiébaut, 1994), and both share certain characteristics with the present works: small round faces, tiny half closed eyes, relatively large hands, and tentative gestures. One of the two panels, the Funeral of the Virgin is particular close to the Treason of Judas. Like Barthelémy d’Eyck and Enguerrand Quarton, Lieferinxe settled in Provence from the North, in his case from Flanders or Picardy. He is established there by 1493, and in 1503, he marries the daughter of the Provencal painter, Jean Changenet. So fragmentary and sparse is the stained glass surviving from Provence that it is difficult to carry further these tentative efforts at a localization and date.
Composed of clear glass, these silver stain panels show black and brown grisaille posed in light layers and delicate stippling and hatching; an irregularity in the blowing of the glass on the panel of Judas, resulted in a slight deformation; on the other panel, a small mark (CIID) is etched into the exterior side in the upper corner.
Literature
Thiébaut, 1994.